Reasons for selecting the sample This study was conducted only on Preparatory and Secondary stages from the General Education System. The elementary stage was eliminated because it ended at the time of this study was applied. The sample from Basic Education includes only teachers from the first and second cycle, Post Basic Education stage was eliminated because reform had not reached this stage when this study was applied
Data collection A questionnaire was developed by the researcher to collect data. It consisted of seven parts: the first part includes two sections (yes, no) and (rating questions) aimed at gathering general information. The second part examines teachers' skills in using software programs. The third part examines the benefit to teachers from internet facilities. The fourth part examines using computer in teaching. The fifth part examines teachers' attitudes towards using computers in teaching. The sixth part examines teachers' knowledge of social studies internet websites. The seventh part examines the benefits to teachers from using social studies internet websites. (See appendix).
Validity and reliability of the questionnaire: The validity of the questionnaire was established by a panel of eight experts in Social Studies Curriculum, Psychology and Instruction Technology Departments at Sultan Qaboos University. Based on the referees' responses, some items were deleted and some were modified. The questionnaire’s reliability was established by using Cronbach's alpha coefficient because it allows an investigation of how well the different items complement each other in their measurement of different aspects of the subject. The value of Cronbach’s Alpha of the questionnaire was (.8556) established from the results of the pilot study.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Questions1: How do social studies teachers rate themselves in computer general information? Data gathered under this question was divided into two sections :Section (A) investigating teacher information about owning computers and their training in the use of computers while section (B) aimed at investigating teacher skills in using computer. Section A: Table (2) shows the percentage of teachers’ ratings of themselves in their command of general information about computers.
Table 2: Percentages of teachers' responses about computer general information
Table (2, item 1) shows that the majority of social studies teachers have their own computers. Around 24% of them do not have computers despite the fact that the Ministry of Education program allows teacher to buy his/her own laptop through an installment program. The high number of teachers who have their own computers is a promising indicator because this reflect their understanding of and attitudes towards the importance of computer in their life, in the teaching and learning process. The results (item 2) also show that the majority of social studies teachers did not attend any computer courses, which means that they just depend on themselves in developing their computer skills. Such results indicate that the Ministry of Education programs for the professional development of teachers neither help in developing these teachers’ computer skills, nor match the spreading the number of computers in Omani schools. The previous results also reflect weakness in pre-service teacher preparation programs in developing graduates’ computer skills. The finding of this study supports the findings of previous studies which showed a lack of teacher computer skills (US Department of Education, 2000; Handler,1993: Oliver,1993, Abdal-Haqq,1995). The results of this and previous studies stress the need to pay more attention to developing teacher computer skill because it is not enough to increase the number of computers in school, as the literature showed; it is more important to have qualified teachers who know how to use them in the teaching and learning process. The finding of (item 3) present that the majority of social studies teachers wish to have computer courses to develop themselves in this field. Such results raise positive sign that social studies teacher are aware of the importance of being qualified in computers, and have high motivation to develop their computer skills if they are provided with computer training courses. This results contradicts of the finding of (Al-Oteawi, 2002) which showed that the lack of teacher knowledge and skill in the use of computers made them hold negative attitudes toward computers. Moreover, the results of item (4) highlights the lack of social studies teachers’ skills in using computers in teaching, where 90.4% of them wish to have computer courses about using computer in teaching. This resultreveals that these teachers believe in the role of computers in the teaching process, and that they feel they have poor skills in this area. Such results indicate that these teachers want to apply computers in their classrooms but they don’t have the necessary skills to this. The results of items (5 and 6) reveal that around 50% of social studies teachers use the internet at home. This result reflect the low degree of benefit of Omani social studies teacher from the internet. This result raises a question mark about the state of our educational system, which looks to the internet as a source of information together with textbooks, so how much can our teachers benefit from provided internet services in school, when half of the social studies teachers do not use the internet?
Section (B): Table (3) shows the extent of teachers' computer use in teaching, their computer skills and the time they spend on the internet. Table 3: Percentage of teachers' using of computer, computer skills and time spent on internet
Interpretation of Mean: from 1 - 1.59 (low), 1.666 - 2.29 (moderate), 2.333 - 3 (high)
The results of (item 7) show that around a third of social studies teachers have poor computer skills, while half of them are fairly skillful. This result indicates a the need for more training in the use of computers because the fact that around a third of teachers have poor computer skills is a negative indicator in the educational process in Oman. The percentage could be higher if we think about the total population of social studies teachers in Oman. Such results reflect the shortage on both pre-service teacher preparation programs and in- service training. Low computer skills have an effect on social studies teachers’ use of computers in teaching, where a third of them do not use computer at all, and half of them use them sometimes ( see item 8). Such a finding may raise questions about the benefit of providing computers and internet services in school, if such a high percentage of teacher are not qualified in computer skills. Even though the number of teachers using computers in their classrooms is not high, this is still an encouraging percentage indicator, which matches the findings of Eteokleous’ 2008 study, which show that a few teachers do use computers in a progressive way. The results of item (9) show that a low level of skill in computer use affects social studies teacher time spent on the internet, where around 40% of them spend just 1 – 5 hours a week and around 50% of them spend over 10 hours a week.
Question 2: How do social studies teachers rate themselves in the skill of using program software, benefiting from internet facilities and using computer in teaching? Table (4) shows means and standard deviations of teacher rating: skills of using program software, benefiting from internet facilities and using computers in teaching.
Table 4: Skills of using program software, benefiting from internet and using computer in teaching
Interpretation of Mean: from 1 - 1.749 (low), 1.75 - 2.5 (moderate), 2.499 – 3.25 (high), 3.499 – 4 (very high)
Findings in domain (1) suggest that teachers’ skill in using program software such as Word, PowerPoint, Flash, Excel, SPSS were moderate, despite their importance in the teaching process, particularly in teaching some topics in social studies such as : population growth, and economic investment etc. This result explains why a third of teachers do not use computers in teaching ( see item 8 in table 3). These results support the findings of ( Bakar & Mohamed, 1998) which show a lack of teacher knowledge and skill in the use software programs. The results of domain (2) show moderate benefit from the internet such as search engines, emails, downloading files, which means that these teachers seem not to be communicating with their students by email because they don’t know how to use it. It also mean that they don’t benefit from the huge amount of information provided by search engines, which means that our students in school are not connected with worldwide information resources. As social studies teachers have only had moderate skill in using program software, their use of computers in the teaching process, such as in presentation, feedback, assessment and the recording of grades was moderate ( see domain 3). These results indicate a need for the educators in the educational system in Oman to rethink the situation regarding the application of computers in the Omani educational system.
Question 3: Do teachers’ rating of themselves in the skill of using program software, benefiting from internet facilities and using computers in teaching differ according to their gender, the stage in which they teach and their region? A- Gender Table (5) shows the results of t-test comparing differences of teacher rating in the three domains according to their gender.
Table 5: Results of t-test
The results reveal that there were no significant differences between male and female teachers rating in the three domains, This result could be due to the fact that all of these teachers had graduated from the same colleges, with generally the same programs, and haven’t had any in-service professional development courses. This result contradicts the results of (Makrakis &Sawada,1996; Liang & Chao, 2002) which showed that males are more skillful and knowledgeable in computer than females.
B. Stage they teach Table (6) shows the results of One Way ANOVA comparing differences of teacher rating in the three domains according to their stage.
Table 6: Results of ANOVA for stage comparisons
According to Table 6, there were significant differences between teachers’ ratings, due to the stage they teach in domain one and domain three. A Tukey post hoc test was used to show the directions of differences. It was found that first and second cycle teachers are more skillful in using computer software program than teachers of the secondary stage. It also showed that second cycle teachers are using computer in teaching more than teachers of the secondary stage. This could be due to the fact that first and second cycle schools are provided with computer labs ( information learning resources lab) as a part of educational reform in Oman and teachers have to use this facility together with textbooks, while at the secondary stage, it is still not applied.
C. Region Table (7) shows the results of One Way ANOVA comparing differences of teacher rating in the three domains according to their regions.
Table 7: Results of one way ANOVA for regions comparisons
According to Table (7) there were significant differences between teachers rating due to the region where they teach in the second and third domain. A Tukey post hoc test was used to show the directions of differences. It was found that Al-Sharqia teachers benefit more from internet facilities than Al-Dakiliah teachers. Al-Sharqia teachers are also using computer in teaching more than Muscat and Al-Dakiliah teachers. This could be the result of the school leadership in those regions motivating teachers to apply information technology in their schools, and also could be due to the teachers themselves having more interested in computers and their applications. This result support the finding of Brinkerhoff & Koroghlanian (2005) which showed differences in teacher skills according to their region.
Question 4: Do teachers’ attitudes toward using computers in teaching differ according to gender, stage, and region? Gender Table (8) shows the grand mean of social studies teachers' attitudes and the mean of their responses according to their gender. Table 8: Results of T-Test
Interpretation of Mean: from 1 - 1.59 (low), 1.66 - 2.299 (moderate), 2.333 - 3 (high)
The results show that the social studies teachers hold high positive attitudes towards using computers in teaching (2.8497). This result is encouraging because most of them did not have computer training. This contradicts the literature, which indicated that teachers who do not have computer training showed negative attitudes towards using computers in teaching ( Al-Oteawi,2002; Pelton and Pelton, 1996). The differences between the findings of this study and previous studies may suggest that Omani teachers’ perceptions of the importance of computers encourage them to develop more positive attitudes towards computer use, despite their lack of knowledge and skills. This study supports the findings of Tondeur et al (2008) which showed that teachers hold positive attitudes towards computer in the educational process. The result also revealed that there were no significant differences between male and females teachers. This result contradicts some previous results which showed that males hold more positive attitudes than females do (Wilder et al, 1985; Masssoud, 1991; Moon et al, 1994; Shashanni, 1996; Makrakis and Sawada, 1996; Durndell and Thomson, 1997) and other studies which showed that females prefer to use computers and have more knowledge than males (Allen,1995). Differences between the results of this study and the previous studies may be due to different cultures, graduating programs, and educational systems.
Stage and Region Table (9) shows the results of One Way ANOVA comparing differences of teacher attitudes according to their stage and region. Table 9: Results of one way ANOVA for the two independent variables: stage and region
Stage: The results show that there were significant differences in teachers' attitudes towards using computers in teaching due to their stage and region. A Tukey post hoc test was used to show the causes of differences. It were found that the secondary stage teachers hold higher positive attitudes compared to those in the first and second cycles. These higher positive attitudes at a time when they lacked knowledge and skills, could be explained by the perception of secondary stage teachers of the importance of computers. It could also be related to their feelings about their lack of such skills, which may personally affect them, compared with teachers who are teaching in the first and second cycle.
Region: The results also show that teachers from Al-Batanah region hold higher positive attitudes than those in Muscat. This result may be due to influence of workshops, teachers’ desire to develop themselves in computer skills, and motivation from teacher supervisors in this region.
Question 4: Are social studies teachers aware of journal and centers of social studies websites on the internet? Table (10) shows the percentage of teachers' knowledge of social studies websites. Table 10: Percentage of teachers' knowledge of social studies websites
The results show that the majority of social studies teachers (80%) do not know any internet website related to journals of social studies in English language, and around 60% of them do not know even internet websites of Arabic journals. The majority of these teachers lack knowledge about internet websites of social studies centers in English language and half of them lack knowledge about internet websites of Arabic social studies centers. These results could be due to the shortage of computer skills and knowledge about benefiting from internet as an information resource. It could also be due to the shortage of workshops which develop teachers’ knowledge about these websites and how to benefit from them. Such results show the extent to which our social studies teachers lack knowledge of such journals’ and centers’ websites. This requires a great deal of consideration from those who are responsible for reforming the educational system in Oman.
Question 5: Do social studies teachers benefit from social studies websites on the internet? Table (11) shows the percentage of teachers' responses.
Table 11: Shows the percentage of teachers' responses
It can be noted from the response to (item 1) that over half of social studies teachers use the internet to get information related to the social studies curriculum, which is a good indicator, but still the websites they use for such information are mainly Arabic ones. Around half of the teachers (item 2 and 3) benefit from the internet in updating and expanding of data in social studies textbooks and in classroom activities. This result reveals a gape in the application of information technology in our schools. This result could be due to the weakness of social studies teachers command of the English language as a possible reason for not been using in English websites. It could be also due to the limited number of Arabic professional websites in education and particularly in social studies. Results of items (4 and 5) show that more than half of social studies teachers are not benefiting from the internet in developing their knowledge about teaching methods and assessment in social studies, although there are a lot of websites in the internet, which provides updated articles related to geography, history, politics, economic and websites which provide activities, games , ideas to social studies teachers to help them with their teaching. Such results need to be considered in the workshops introduced by the Ministry of Education for in-service social studies teachers, to equip them with knowledge and skills which would allow them to benefit from these websites. The result item 6 reveal that the majority of social studies teachers do not communicate with specialists or experts in their field; this could be due to poor internet skills and poor English language skills.
CONCLUSION AND SUGGESTIONS It can be noted from the results above that there some positive indicators about social studies teachers in Oman in the area of applying computers in the teaching process. Teachers hold positive attitudes towards the importance of computers in teaching ,and are concerned about developing their skills, since they wish to attend computer skills training sessions. However, there are some negative indicators which suggest that the Ministry of Education in Oman needs to spend more time and effort on developing teacher skills in using computer program software, using the internet, using computers in teaching, and developing their knowledge about social studies internet websites (journals, centers etc) both in Arabic and English language. The situation of social studies teachers now is not encouraging because most of them lack computer knowledge and skills, which negatively affects their use of computers in the teaching process. The study suggests conducting more research in this field to investigate the views of human resources development personally in the Ministry of Education about the situation of teachers’ computer skills, and teacher views about types of in-service training courses they need in this area. It is also suggested that courses or workshops in program software, internet and its application, and the use of computers in teaching need to be introduced. The study suggests that pre-service teacher-training programs need to do a lot more to develop the abilities of their graduates in computer skills before going to the classroom. It also suggests that the Ministry of Education needs to consider that the increase in the number of computers and internet services in schools will require that teachers should be qualified in computer skills. Technicians cannot be expected to sort out weaknesses in the system which result from a deficiency in teachers’ skills.
Suggested studies:
REFERENCES Abdal-Haqq, I (1995) Infusing technology into pre-service teacher education. ERIC Digest 389699 Akengin, H. (2007). Egitim Programlarinda Cografyanim Yeri Nedir? Cografya Nasil Ogretilmelidir? (What is the Locus of Geography in the Curriculum? How must be Geography Taught?). Ilkogretimde Alan Ogretimi [Ed.: Ayla Oktay, Ozgiil Polat Unutkan]. Istanbul: Morpa pp. 143-158 Albion, P. (2001) Some factors in the development of self-efficacy belief for computer use among teacher education students. Journal of Technology and Teacher Education, 9 (3), 321- 341. Allen, B. (1995) Gender and computer -mediated communication. Sex Roles: A Journal of Research, 32(7-8), 557-564. Al-Oteawi, S. (2002) The perceptions of Administrators and teachers in utilizing information technology in instruction, administrative work, technology planning and staff development in Saudi Arabia .Doctoral Dissertation, Ohio University. Bakar, Ab.Rahim and Mohamed, S. (1998) Preparing Malaysian vocational and technology teachers to integrate computer technology in teaching vocational and technology subjects, Computer and Education, 31(4), 365 – 372. Bird, T; and Rosaen, C. (2005) Providing authentic contexts for learning information technology in teacher preparation, Journal of Technology and Teacher Education, 13(2), 211- 131. Brinkerhoff, J; and Koroghlanian, C. (2005) Students computer skills and attitudes toward internet-deeliverd instruction: an assessment of stability over time and place, Journal of Educational Computing Research, 32(1), 27 – 56. Budin, H. (1991). Technology And The Teacher's Role. Computers In The Schools. 8, (1/2/3) 15-26. Bullock, D. (2004) Moving from theory to practice: an examination of the factors that preservice teachers encounter as they attempt to gain experience teaching with technology during field placement experience, Journal of Technology and Teacher Education, 12(2), 211 –237. Christensen, R., and Knezek, G. (2001). Instruments for assessing the impact of technology in education. Computers in the Schools, 18(2/3), 5-25. Cuban, L. (2001) Oversold and underused: computers in the classroom. Cambridge,MA: Harvard University Press. Davidson, John. (1996) Information technology and the geography department. In Bailey,P and Fozx, P.(eds) Geography teachers’ handbook. The Geographical Association. P249 – 260 Durndell, A., and Thomson, K. (1997) Gender and computing: a decade of change?. Computers in Education, 28 (1), 1-9. Eteokleous, N. (2008) Evaluating computer technology integration in a centralized school system, Computers and Education 51 (2008) 669–686 Galligan, J. (1995). Computers And Pedagogy. Paper Presented At Australian Computers In Education Conference. 1995. Perth, Western Australia. Galanouli, D; Murphy, C and Gardner, J.(2004) Teachers_ perceptions of the effectiveness of ICT-competence training, Computers and Education 43 (2004) 63–79. Handler, M. (1993) “Preparing new teachers to use computer technology: perceptions and suggestions for teacher educators”, Computers and Education, 20 (2), 147-156. Hassell, David. (2000) Issues in ICT and geography. In Fisher,C and Binns, (eds) Issues in geography teaching. London and New York: Routledge Falmer, P80 – 92. Healy, J. (1998) Failure to connect: How computers affect our children’s mids- and what we can do about it. New York: Touchstone. Heywood, G and Norman, P. (1988). Problems of educational innovation: the primary teacher’s response to using the microcomputers, Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 4(1) 34 –43. Huke, R.E., Fielding, G.J. and Rumage, K.W. (1969) Computer Assisted Instruction in Geography, AAG Commission on College Geography, Technical Paper No. 2. Washington, D.C.: Association of American Geographers Johnston, V. (1987) Attitudes towards microcomputer in learning, 1: pupils and software fro language development, Educational Research, 29 (1) 47 – 55. Jonassen, D. (1996) Computers In The Classroom: Mindtools For Critical Thinking. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Merrill Pub. Keiffer, R.D., Hale, M.E., and Templeton, A. (1998). Electronic literacy portfolios: Technology transformations in a first-grade classroom. In D. Reinking, M.C. McKenna, and L.D. Labbo (Eds.), Handbook of literacy and technology: Transformation in a post-typographic world, (pp. 145-163). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Lewis, S. (1995). Student-created virtual tours, Learning and Leading with Technology 23 (2),35-39. Liang, M; and Chao, M. (2002) Investigation into the Internet literacy of elementary and junior high school teachers inTaiwan, World Transactions on Engineering and Technology Education, 1(1),129 – 132 Makrakis, V., and Sawada, T. (1996) Gender, computers and other school subjects among Japanese and Swedish students. Computers in Education, 26 (4), 225-231. Marankiewicz,H. (1994) Computers and teachers: factors influencing computer use in the classroom", Journal of Research on Computing in Education, 26(2), 220 –237. Mason C., Bergson M., Diem, R., Hick, D., Lee, J., and Dralle, T. (2000). Guidelines for using technology to prepare social studies teachers. Contemporary Issues in Technology and Teacher Education. 1 (1), 107-116. URL: http://www/citejournal.org/voll1/issl/ currentissues/socialstudies/article1.htm Retrieved at 21st May, 2007. Massoud, S. (1991) Computer attitudes and computer knowledge of adult students. Journal of Educational Computing Research, 7 (3), 269-291. McAllister, M; and Mitchell, M. (2002) Enriching learning using web and computer technologies: how not to throw caution to the wind. Nurse Education in Practice, (2) p 125 – 132. McKinney, M. (1998). Preservice teachers' electronic portfolios: Integrating technology, self-assessment, and reflection. Teacher Education Quarterly, 25, 85-103. Moon, S. and Kim,J. (1994) The relationships among gender, computer experience, and attitudes toward computers. Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Mid-South Educational Research Association, Nashville, TN. November 9-11,. (ERIC NO: ED381142). NCATE: National Council for Accreditation of Teacher Education (NCATE) (1997). Technology and the new professional teacher: Preparing for the 21st century classroom. Washington, DC: NCATE Oliver, R. (1993) The influence of training on beginning teachers’ use of computer, Australian Educational Computing, July, 189 –196. Oliver, T. and Shapiro, F. (1993) Self-efficacy and computers, Journal of Computer-Based Instruction, 20(3), 81- 85. Pelgrum, W. (2001) Obstacles to the integration of ICT in education: results from a worldwide educational assessment, Computer and Education, 37, 163 – 178. Pelton, L., and Pelton, T.W. (1996). Building attitudes: How a technology courses affects preservice teachers' attitudes about technology. In B. Robin, J. D. Price J. Willis, and D. A. Willis (Eds.), Technology and Teacher Education Annual, (pp. 167-172). Roberts, D., and Allbion, P.(1993) Computers in Australian secondary schools, Australian Educational Computing, 8 (July) 217 – 224. Rose, S. and Ferlund. P. (1997). Using Technology For Powerful Social Studies Learning, Social Education. 61, 3. 160-166. Rose, S. A. and Phyllis M. F. (1997). Using Technology for Powerful Social Studies Learning. Social Education, 61 (3), 60-66 Russell, M., Bebell, D., Dwyer, L and O’Connor,K. (2003) Examining teacher technology use implications for preservice and inservice teacher preparation, Journal of Teacher Education, 54(4) September/ October, 297 – 310. Shashaani, L. (1997) Gender differences in computer attitudes and use among college students, Journal of Educational Computing Research, 16 (1), 37-51. Shavinina, L.V. (1997). Educational multimedia of "tomorrow": High intellectual and creative psycho educational technologies. Presented at the European congress of psychology, Dublin, Ireland. Aprip 19-19. Sterling, J., and Gray, M.(1991) The effect of simulation software on students’ attitudes and understanding in the introductory statistics, Journal of Computer Mathematic and Science Teaching, 10(4), 51 – 55. Stoll, C. (1999) High-tech heretic. New York. Random House. Sunal, C. S. and Haas, M: E. (2002). Social Studies for the Elementary and Middle Grades. A Constructivist Approach. Boston: A Person Education Company. TAAP. (1996). "Technology for All Americans Project." Technology for All Americans: A rationale and Structure for the Study of Technology. Reston, VA: International Technology Education Association. Thomas, G. (2003). Globalization of educational technology, Issues in Education, 23, 34-40 Tondeur, J., Hermans, R., Van Braak, J. and Valcke, M. (2008) Exploring the link between teachers’ educational belief profiles and different types of computer use in the classroom, Computers in Human Behavior xxx (2008) xxx–xxx (under print (Science Direct, ELSVIER) Unwin, D (1991) "Using computers to help students learn: computer assisted learning in geography", Area, 23(1): 25-34. US Department of Education (2000) Preparing tomorrow’s teachers to use technology(PT3). Retrieved March 27,2002, from: http://www.ed.gov/teachtech/ Vanfossen, P. (2001) Degree of internet/www use and barriers to use among secondary social studies teachers. International Journal of Instructional Media, Winter, (28) 57 – 72. Vermette, S., R. Orr, and M. Hall. (1986). Attitudes of elementary school students and teachers toward computer education, Educational Technology, 26, 41-46 Watson, D. (1998) Blame the technocentric artifact! What research tells us about problems inhibiting teacher use of IT. In Marshall, G ; and Ruohonen , M. (Eds), Capacity building fro IT in education developing countries, pp 185 – 192. London: Chapman and Hall. Wilder, G., Mackie, D., and Cooper, J. (1985) Gender and computers: Two surveys of computer related attitudes. Sex Roles: A Journal of Research, 13 (3 - 4), 215 - 228.
APPENDIX Omani social studies teachers' knowledge skills and attitudes in using computer in instructions This study aims at acknowledging your computer skills, attitudes and its application in instruction. Gathered information will be confidential and it will only used for research purposes.
Gender: …………………………. Region: ………………………………………….
Stage in which you teach: ……………………………………………………………
Please put tick in the box which express your computer skills, attitudes and its application in instructions.
Section 1: (A): General information:
Section 2: Program software
Section 3: Benefiting from internet facilities
Section 4: Using computer in teaching
Section 5: Attitudes toward using computer in teaching
Section 6: knowledge of journal and centers of social studies websites
Section 7: Benefiting of social studies websites
Copyright for articles published in this journal is retained by the authors, with first publication rights granted to the journal. By virtue of their appearance in this open access journal, articles are free to use, with proper attribution, in educational and other non-commercial settings. Original article at: http://ijedict.dec.uwi.edu//viewarticle.php?id=562&layout=html
|